Understanding the difference between disbursements and recharges is essential for law firms that regularly incur costs on behalf of clients. Although both involve recovering expenses, their VAT treatment can be significantly different.
A genuine disbursement is generally outside the scope of VAT, whereas an expense recharge normally forms part of the solicitor's own supply of legal services and is subject to the applicable VAT rate.
Incorrectly classifying these payments can lead to underpaid VAT, inaccurate invoices, HMRC assessments and potential penalties.
This guide from the VAT specialists at The VAT People explains the disbursement vs recharge VAT rules, how they apply to common legal expenses and what law firms should consider when invoicing clients.
What is the difference between a disbursement and a recharge?
The main difference between a disbursement and a recharge is whether the law firm pays a third-party expense as an agent for its client or incurs the expense as part of providing its own services.
A disbursement is a payment made to a third party on the client's behalf, where the client receives the relevant goods or services and is responsible for the cost. Provided HMRC's conditions are satisfied, the solicitor can recover the exact amount without adding VAT.
A recharge occurs when a law firm incurs expenses while providing its own legal services and subsequently passes those costs to the client. These expenses form part of the firm's supply and generally attract VAT at the same rate as the legal services.
For example, Stamp Duty Land Tax paid by a solicitor on a client's behalf will generally qualify as a disbursement. However, travel costs incurred by a solicitor attending a client meeting are normally business expenses, even where the firm charges those costs separately.
The distinction matters because describing an expense as a disbursement on an invoice does not automatically make it one for VAT purposes.
What counts as a disbursement for VAT purposes?
HMRC sets out specific conditions that businesses must satisfy before treating a payment as a disbursement for VAT purposes.
Under VAT Notice 700, section 25, the relevant conditions are:
- The law firm acts as an agent for its client when paying the third party.
- The client actually receives and uses the goods or services supplied by the third party.
- The client is responsible for paying the third party.
- The client authorises the law firm to make the payment on their behalf.
- The client knows that the goods or services are being provided by a third party.
- The law firm separately itemises the payment on its invoice.
- The law firm recovers only the exact amount paid to the third party.
- The goods or services paid for are additional to the services supplied by the law firm itself.
All the applicable conditions must be satisfied. A payment will not qualify simply because the client has agreed to reimburse the firm or the expense appears separately on a bill.
For example, a law firm might pay a Companies House registration fee on behalf of a client. If the client is responsible for the fee and the firm acts solely as a payment agent, the amount may qualify as a disbursement.
However, where the firm purchases information or services for use in delivering its own legal advice, the cost may instead be part of its taxable supply.
Are disbursements outside the scope of VAT?
Genuine disbursements are outside the scope of VAT, meaning the law firm does not add VAT when recovering the payment from its client.
This is different from zero-rated or VAT-exempt supplies. A genuine disbursement is not consideration for a supply made by the law firm.
If the third-party supplier charges VAT, that VAT may still form part of the amount paid on the client's behalf. The law firm should not automatically reclaim it as its own input tax.
What is an expense recharge for VAT purposes?
An expense recharge occurs when a law firm recovers costs it has incurred while providing services to a client.
These are usually normal business costs rather than payments made as an agent on the client's behalf.
Examples include:
- Travel expenses incurred when attending meetings or court.
- Accommodation and subsistence expenses.
- Printing, photocopying and administrative costs.
- Courier charges incurred in delivering legal services.
- Bank transfer fees incurred by the firm when administering transactions.
Even where the firm charges these expenses separately, they will generally remain part of its own supply.
For example, if a solicitor purchases a train ticket to attend court, the transport service is supplied to the solicitor. The firm cannot treat the cost as a VAT disbursement merely because the client agrees to pay for it.
Where the underlying legal services are standard-rated, the recharge will normally be subject to VAT at 20%.
The position may differ where the underlying supply is exempt, zero-rated or subject to another treatment. Law firms should therefore consider the VAT liability of the overall service rather than applying a blanket rule to every recharge.
Disbursements vs recharges: common examples for law firms
Law firms regularly encounter payments that can be difficult to classify. The correct VAT treatment depends on the circumstances of each transaction.
| Expense | Typical VAT treatment | Important consideration |
|---|---|---|
| Stamp Duty Land Tax | Genuine disbursement | The tax is the client's liability and is paid on their behalf |
| Court fees | Often a genuine disbursement | The client must be responsible for the fee and HMRC's conditions must be met |
| Land Registry registration fees | May qualify as a disbursement | Depends on whether the firm acts as an agent for the client |
| Property search fees | Often a taxable recharge | Searches used by solicitors to provide legal advice generally form part of their own services |
| Medical reports and records | Depends on the circumstances | Consider who receives and uses the information and the purpose for which it is obtained |
| Travel and accommodation | Normally a taxable recharge | These are usually expenses incurred in providing legal services |
| Bank transfer fees | Normally a taxable recharge | Fees charged to the firm's business account are generally its own costs |
| Companies House fees | May qualify as a disbursement | The client must be responsible for the payment and the agency conditions must be satisfied |
Property searches and the Brabners case
Property search fees are particularly important for conveyancing firms.
In Brabners LLP v HMRC, the First-tier Tribunal considered electronic property searches obtained by solicitors and used in providing legal advice.
The tribunal concluded that the search costs formed part of the firm's own legal services rather than qualifying as disbursements.
This demonstrates why the way a solicitor uses third-party information is relevant when determining the VAT treatment.
HMRC also withdrew its former concession concerning postal property searches from 1 December 2020. Law firms should not assume that a search fee qualifies as a disbursement simply because it is charged separately.
Further information is available in HMRC's guidance on the VAT treatment of property search fees.
Court fees and other payments made on a client's behalf
Court fees are commonly treated as disbursements where the solicitor pays a fee for proceedings involving the client and satisfies HMRC's conditions.
However, the correct treatment should still be established rather than assumed.
The same principle applies to registration fees, certain statutory payments and costs associated with obtaining medical records.
How should law firms charge VAT on recharged expenses?
Where a recharge forms part of a standard-rated legal service, the law firm must normally charge VAT at 20% on the amount charged to the client.
Importantly, the VAT treatment of the original expense does not necessarily determine the VAT treatment of the recharge.
For example, passenger rail travel is generally zero-rated for VAT. However, where a solicitor incurs rail travel costs while providing standard-rated legal services and recharges those costs to the client, the recharge will normally attract 20% VAT.
Example: Recharging travel expenses
A solicitor incurs £100 in rail travel expenses while attending a client meeting.
| Description | Amount |
|---|---|
| Travel expenses recharged | £100 |
| VAT at 20% | £20 |
| Total charged to client | £120 |
Although the train ticket itself did not attract VAT, the £100 recharge forms part of the solicitor's standard-rated legal services.
The same principle generally applies to air fares, accommodation and other travelling expenses incurred in delivering legal work.
If a law firm adds a handling fee or markup, that additional amount will normally form part of the taxable consideration.
Reimbursement vs disbursement VAT: is there a difference?
The terms reimbursement, disbursement and recharge are sometimes used interchangeably, but they do not necessarily have the same meaning for VAT purposes.
A reimbursement simply means that one party repays another for an amount spent.
For example, a client might reimburse a solicitor for travel costs, or repay a court fee that the solicitor paid on their behalf.
However, reimbursement alone does not establish the correct VAT treatment.
If the law firm incurred the expense in providing its own services, the reimbursement is generally a taxable recharge.
If the firm paid a third-party liability as an agent for the client and all HMRC conditions are met, the payment may qualify as a genuine disbursement.
Therefore, when considering reimbursement vs disbursement VAT, the important question is not what the payment is called, but who received the goods or services and who was responsible for the expense.
Can law firms reclaim input VAT on disbursements and recharges?
The distinction between disbursements and recharges also affects input VAT recovery.
Where a VAT-registered law firm incurs expenses for its own taxable business activities, it can generally reclaim eligible input VAT, subject to the normal rules and any applicable restrictions.
For example, if a law firm purchases consultancy services to support its own taxable legal work, the VAT charged by the consultant may be recoverable as input tax.
The firm must hold appropriate evidence, normally including a valid VAT invoice.
Where those consultancy costs are subsequently recharged to a client, the firm must also account for output VAT on the recharge where required.
Genuine disbursements are different.
If a law firm pays a supplier on the client's behalf as an agent, the goods or services are supplied to the client rather than the firm. Any VAT charged by the supplier is therefore not ordinarily the law firm's input tax.
The firm should recover the amount paid without adding its own VAT, provided the disbursement conditions are satisfied.
Where a law firm incurs VAT on eligible business expenses, the amount recoverable must be calculated and recorded correctly. Our guide to calculating input VAT explains how input tax is determined and accounted for through VAT returns.
For further guidance, see our article explaining input and output VAT.
How should disbursements and recharges appear on a solicitor's invoice?
Accurate VAT invoicing is essential for law firms because incorrectly classifying disbursements can result in underpaid VAT, HMRC assessments, interest and potential penalties.
It also ensures clients are charged the correct amount and that VAT-registered clients receive the documentation needed to reclaim eligible input VAT.
Genuine disbursements should be separately itemised and clearly distinguished from taxable legal fees and expense recharges.
Example of a solicitor's VAT invoice
Assume a law firm provides standard-rated legal services and incurs both a taxable expense recharge and a genuine disbursement.
| Invoice item | Net amount | VAT | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Legal services | £1,000 | £200 | £1,200 |
| Travel expense recharge | £100 | £20 | £120 |
| Court fee qualifying as a disbursement | £150 | £0 | £150 |
| Court fee qualifying as a disbursement | £1,250 | £220 | £1,470 |
In this example, the court fee is outside the scope of VAT because it meets the conditions for a genuine disbursement.
The travel expense recharge attracts VAT because it forms part of the firm's standard-rated legal services.
Law firms should verify their accounting software and billing procedures distinguish between these categories correctly. An invoice should not describe an expense as outside the scope of VAT unless the treatment can be supported.
What happens if a law firm gets the VAT treatment wrong?
Incorrectly treating recharged expenses as disbursements can result in a law firm failing to account for VAT that should have been charged.
If HMRC identifies an error, the firm may face:
- Additional VAT liabilities: HMRC may assess VAT that should have been accounted for on taxable recharges.
- Interest: Interest may arise on VAT paid late.
- Penalties: Depending on the circumstances and the firm's behaviour, penalties may apply.
- Client billing disputes: Incorrect invoices can lead to disagreements over additional VAT charges.
- Administrative costs: Historic transactions may need to be reviewed and VAT returns or invoices corrected.
A further risk arises where a firm incorrectly reclaims input VAT on payments that should have been treated as genuine disbursements.
Law firms should retain evidence of the original supplier invoices, client authorisation and the basis on which each payment was classified.
How can law firms check the correct VAT treatment?
Law firms should establish consistent procedures for distinguishing disbursements and recharges before issuing invoices.
A practical review should consider:
- Who is responsible for the expense? Establish whether the liability belongs to the client or the law firm.
- Who receives the goods or services? Determine whether the third-party supply is made to the client or used by the firm in providing legal advice.
- Was the payment authorised? Confirm that the client agreed to the firm paying the third party on their behalf.
- Is the exact amount recovered? Genuine disbursements should not include a markup.
- How is the cost recorded? Ensure invoices and accounting records distinguish disbursements from taxable recharges.
- Has input VAT been treated correctly? Check that the firm has not reclaimed VAT belonging to a supply made to its client.
- Is the classification consistent? Review recurring costs, particularly property searches, travel expenses and bank transfer fees.
Regular checks can help identify errors before they affect multiple VAT returns or attract HMRC scrutiny.
For broader guidance, see The VAT People's VAT compliance checklist.
How can The VAT People help law firms with disbursements and recharges?
Determining the correct VAT treatment of disbursements and recharges can be challenging, particularly where law firms incur a wide range of third-party expenses during conveyancing, litigation and other specialist legal work.
With decades of experience, The VAT People provides specialist VAT advice to solicitors and law firms across the UK.
Several members of our team previously worked and trained within HMRC, providing valuable first-hand insight into the department's processes, compliance approach and investigation procedures.
This experience helps us identify potential risks, assess the correct VAT treatment and support law firms in meeting their obligations.
Our services include:
- Disbursement and recharge reviews: Assessing third-party payments to determine whether they qualify as genuine disbursements or taxable recharges.
- VAT invoicing advice: Reviewing billing procedures to ensure legal fees, disbursements and recharged expenses are treated correctly.
- Input VAT recovery: Advising on when VAT incurred on legal expenses can be reclaimed.
- VAT compliance checks: Identifying historic errors and recommending improvements to accounting procedures.
- HMRC investigations and disputes: Supporting law firms facing HMRC enquiries, assessments or challenges to their VAT treatment.
- VAT training: Helping legal and finance teams apply the rules consistently.
Whether your firm needs clarification on a particular expense or a comprehensive review of its VAT procedures, The VAT People can provide practical, tailored advice.
Speak to The VAT People
Learn more about our specialist VAT services for solicitors.
For expert advice on disbursements, recharges and VAT compliance, contact The VAT People on 0161 477 6600 or complete our online contact form.
