Pension scheme at risk of losing £60k

  • The VAT People were brought in by a client in 2013 to assist with the recovery of VAT paid on the purchase and refurbishment of a new property

  • The client, a pension scheme, was at risk of losing VAT of approximately £60,000 when an application was incorrectly rejected by HMRC

The case

A case brought to us in 2013 was typical of the type of issues our team is used to working out at The VAT People, and we were pleased to find a solution for our client. In this instance, the case involved a client - a pension scheme - paying VAT on the purchase of a new property, while also paying VAT on the significant cost of refurbishing the property.

The client applied to register for VAT in 2013 in order to be able to recover the relevant costs, and notified the HMRC of its decision to “opt to tax” the property. This decision meant the client was able to charge VAT on the rent that it was due to charge for the refurbished property, and in return, should have been able to recover the VAT incurred on the cost of refurbishment. HMRC raised numerous queries in relation to the application. However, because the client did not respond, the application was effectively cancelled.

Realising its error, our client submitted a fresh application in 2015, attempting to backdate the VAT registration and option to tax to 2013. HMRC, however, rejected this application, stating that it would only allow the client to register for VAT with effect from a current date. As a result, the client stood to lose VAT of approximately £60,000 in the event this decision was maintained by HMRC.

At this point, The VAT People was brought in to advise.

How we helped

We helped our client by reviewing the relevant case files and considering the law to formulate an argument claiming that HMRC had been wrong to deny the backdating of the VAT registration. We then submitted a formal request for the decision in question to be reviewed. Following a period of discussion, HMRC agreed to backdate the VAT registration, as well as the option to tax, meaning the client would be in a position to recover the VAT of £60,000.

When asked about their dealings with the VAT People, and our director, Rob McCann, the client said: “We have previously worked with Rob and found him to be very efficient and effective at eliciting a successful response from HMRC.  

“We provided sufficient information for Rob to negotiate with HMRC and as a result of his work, they ultimately reversed their position and confirmed that the VAT registration could be backdated. The fees charged by Rob were very reasonable and he kept us informed of progress throughout the process.  We would not hesitate to recommend Rob and to use him again should another specialist VAT problem arise.

Key takeaways/learnings

  • Always respond to communication from HMRC in a timely manner.

  • Adopt a VAT plan following all property purchase and improvement projects, and importantly ensure that the plan in question is implemented properly.

  • The VAT treatment of projects involving land and property is often complex and thus advice should be sought in order to remove the risk of costly mistakes.

  • Do not assume that a decision made by HMRC is not open to challenge.  Run any adverse decision by The VAT People.

Contact us

Our expert team of VAT consultants has years of experience in handling all aspects of VAT. Discuss your circumstances with a consultant by calling 01614776600, or fill out an online form and we will be in touch.

Latest Testimonials

  • "The Trustees for Methodist Church Purposes have had a close relationship with The VAT People for the past seven years as they have helped to steer us through the complex process of reclaiming overpaid VAT and successfully accomplishing our de-registration from VAT. They have been able to quickly grasp the nature of our organisation and clearly see the arguments needed to persuade HMRC of our case. The VAT People also had the persistence to continue pursuing our claim until a satisfactory outcome.

    Rob McCann has always made time to be available whenever his expertise has been required to explain the ongoing situation to our governing trustees and committees. His helpful nature and ability to understand and explain complicated areas of the law has been appreciated and valued.

    Simon Kevin Speechley - May
  • "Client service is of the utmost importance to us as a firm of Accountants and Business Advisors.

    Having the ability to be able to contact David Miller for immediate advice on VAT and Customs issues ensures that we are able to deliver our efficient tax service successfully and fulfil our client's expectations, especially in circumstances when they ask for guidance on crucial matters which require a tight deadline.

    Having the ability to engage David's service to attend client's HMRC visits has proved invaluable, particularly as David's knowledge is often superior to that of the Officer in attendance!

    David also offers creative planning solutions to problems and is very proactive with advice as soon as any legislation changes are known. We could not offer the same quality of service to our clients without David and his team."

    Annette Stone, Mark Holt and Co - May
  • "Tamara was my first port of call when I needed a VAT expert. She is extremely knowledgeable, dependable, thorough and efficient. I would recommend her personally to any business needing this kind of assistance."

    Sarah Sillars OBE, CEO at Institute of Advanced Motorists, IAM - April
  • "The VAT People have been used by Cosmo Leisure for many years. We have found them to be very thorough and professional in all that they do.
    They have looked after some very complicated tax issues for us, always meeting deadlines at short notice and pursuing successful claims."

    Keith Lee, Cosmo Leisure Group - April
  • "We have used the services of the VAT people for many years and our point of contact is Steve Howard.

    We especially make use of the free help line which is marvellous.

    Steve is fantastic to deal with and he always provides speedy response, excellent answers to our queries and delivers value for money

    We would not hesitate to recommend the company and especially Steve to any of our clients or business colleagues"

    David Finlayson, Finlayson (UK) Limited - April
  • "Tamara has advised a number of our clients on VAT-related matters and her advice has always been timely and relevant. She is also willing to discuss matters on an informal basis and could not be more helpful. I recommend her and her firm whole-heartedly."

    Adam Hymes, Commercial Property Partner at Kuit Steinart Levy LLP - April
Read All Testimonials

VAT Helpline


We're Here To Assist

Our helpline is free, and you can speak to a member of The VAT People for an initial discussion about any concerns, queries or questions you may have,

Find out more

Useful Information


Watch Our Videos

Get the vital information you need quickly and easily by watching one of our guidance videos - topics include VAT assessments and penalties, VAT for charities, and maximising VAT recovery.

View Videos

Meet the Team

Get in Touch